计算机科学 ›› 2018, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (12): 1-11.doi: 10.11896/j.issn.1002-137X.2018.12.001
• 综述 • 下一篇
黄俏娟, 罗旭东
HUANG Qiao-juan, LUO Xu-dong
摘要: 人工智能并没有一个统一的定义,但若一个计算机系统能做人需要智能才能做的事,一般便认为这样的计算机系统具有人工智能。因此,人工智能被广泛应用于许多需要人类智能的领域,如法律、医疗、金融、电子商务等,其中法律是当前的一个重要应用领域。因此,文中主要从立法(人工智能系统辅助立法以及立法监管人工智能系统,特别是自主驾驶汽车)、知法守法(法律信息的检索、法律文书的生成和审核)、司法(证据收集、法律推理以及在线纠纷解决)等方面综述了人工智能和法律结合的研究现状以及发展趋势,希望能引导更多人投入这个研究领域。
中图分类号:
[1]RICH E.Artificial intelligence.McGraw-Hill Book Co,1985. [2]BERMAN M D.Court finds cooperation in discovery to be an ethical obligation.Journal of the American Dental Association,2016,55(2):181-191. [3]WANG T M,TAO Y,LIU H.Current researches and future development trend of intelligent robot:areview.International Journal of Automation & Computing,2011,15(9):1-22. [4]KROES D.Eulaunches world’s largest civilian robotics pro-gramme.https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-launces-worlds-largest-civilian-robotics-programme/. [5]SIEGEL H,PITONAKOVA L.Best practices in designing effective roadmaps for robotics innovation.https://robohub.org/best-practices-in-designing-effective-roadmaps-for-ro-botics-innovation/. [6]BOYLE A.Obama White House issues its parting policy viewson AI and the social safety net.https://www.geekwire.com/2016/white-house-policy-ai-social-safety-net/. [7]WOOLARD K.The bilingual courtroom:court interpreters inthe judicial process.Journal of Linguistic Anthropology,2010,2(2):229-231. [8]JIANG Y Z,WANG J,XIE Z P,et al.Thinking and applications of AItechnology in digital media education.Journal of Wuxi Institute of Technology,2017,16(1):20-42.(in Chinese) 蒋亦樟,王骏,谢振平,等.智能技术在数字媒体专业教学的思考与应用.无锡职业技术学院学报,2017,16(1):20-42. [9]HOLCOMB S D,PORTER W K,AULT S V,et al.Overview on DeepMind and its AlphaGoZero AI [C]∥Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Big Data and Education.2018:67-71. [10]LIU H,LIU Y.An analysis of the practical difficulties and ways to improve the reform of the system of judges’ posts.Journal of Jiamusi Vocational Institute,2016(7):484-487.(in Chinese) 刘欢,刘洋.试析法官员额制改革的现实困境与完善途径.佳木斯职业学院学报,2016(7):484-487. [11]KATHRANI P.Artificial intelligence and the future of law .Artificial Intelligence & Law,2017,10(10):78-84. [12]MISHRA Y C,TUCKER D K.Method and remote system for creating a customized server infrastructure in real time:U.S.Patent Application No 12/140,968.2009. [13]DYMITRUK M,MARKOVICH R,LIEPINA R,et al.Research in progress:report on the ICAIL 2017 doctoral consortium.Artificial Intelligence & Law,2018,26(1):49-97. [14]DONG J J.Rawls and natural justice:the law of peoples in view of the yin yang theory in the book of change.Journal of Ethi-cs,2008(29):31-43. [15]KNUTH K H.Intelligent machines in the twenty-first century:Foundations of inference and inquiry.Philosophical Transactions on Mathematical Physical & Engineering Sciences,2003,361(1813):2859-2873. [16]DU J,DU Y H,ZHAO X.The research of network cluster behavior mode in online public opinion.Applied Mechanics & Materials,2013,411-414:244-250. [17]TU Y Q,YU H.Participatory evolution of artificial intelligence in judicial adjudication.Journal of Southwest University of Political Science & Law,2018,20(3):48-55.(in Chinese) 涂永前,于涵.司法审判中人工智能的介入式演进.西南政法大学学报,2018,20(3):48-55. [18]NISSAN E,MARTINO A A.The construction of judicial proof:A challenge for artificial intelligence modelling.Applied Artificial Intelligence,2004,18(3):183-184. [19]MORASH M.The application of social impact assessment to the study of criminal and juvenile justice programs:a case study.Journal of Criminal Justice,1983,11(3):229-240. [20]GOVERNATORI G,IDELBERGER F,MILOSEVIC Z,et al.On legal contracts,imperative and declarative smart contracts,and blockchain systems .Artificial Intelligence & Law,2018,26(5):1-33. [21]JIANG Y C.Research on quick resolution mechanism of small-denomination online shopping disputes.Journal of China University of Petroleum,2017,33(2):48-52.(in Chinese) 姜英超.小额网购纠纷在线快速解决机制研究.中国石油大学学报(社会科学版),2017,33(2):48-52. [22]CARNEIRO D,ZELEZNOKOW J,NEVES J.Using case-based reasoning and principled negotiation to provide decision support for dispute resolution.Knowledge &Information Systems,2013,36(3):789-826. [23]KATSH E E,KATSH M E,RIFKIN J.Online dispute resolution:resolving conflicts in cyberspace .New York:John Wiley & Sons,2001:1-5. [24]ZOU Y S.The traditional “non-litigation” idea and the perfection of the contemporary diversified dispute solution mechanism.Law Science Magazine,2016,37(10):73-79.(in Chinese) 邹亚莎.传统无讼理念与当代多元化纠纷解决机制的完善.法学杂志,2016,37(10):73-79. [25]GAO Z X.The impact of united statex agricultural subsidies onworld trade in context of the brazilcotton dispute .https://publicpolicy.wharton.upenn.edu/live/news/851-the-imp-act-of-united-states-agricultural-subsidies. [26]KATSH E,RABINOVICH E O.Access to digital justice:tech-nology and the internet ofdisputes ∥Digital Justice.Oxford University Press,2017:1-9. [27]CONTINI F,LANZARA G F.The circulation of agency in e-justice:Interoperability and infrastructures for European transborder judicial proceedings.Springer Science & Business Media,2013. [28] BOWCOTT O.Online court proposed to resolve claims of up to £25000 .https://www.theguardian.com/law/2015/feb/16/online-court-proposed-to-resolve-claims-of-up-to-25000. [29]CLARK E,CHO G,HOYLE A.Online dispute resolution:present realities,pressing problems and future prospects.International Review of Law Computers & Technology,2003,17(1):7-25. [30]ROSENTHAL E.Who’s afraid of national laws? Pesticide corporations use trade negotiations to avoid bans and undercut public health protections in central America.International Journal of Occupational & Environmental Health,2005,11(4):437-443. [31]LONG X N,WANG J.Local judicial protectionism in china:anempirical study of people’s supreme court IPcases.China Economic Studies,2014(3):3-18.(in Chinese) 龙小宁,王俊.中国司法地方保护主义:基于知识产权案例的研究.中国经济问题,2014(3):3-18. [32] CARTER S.A guide to the UK legal system .http://www.nyulawglobal.org/globa-lex/United_Kingdom.html. [33] LUO X D,MIAO C Y,NICHOLAS N R,et al.KEMNAD:Aknowledge engineering methodology for negotiating agent development.Computational Intelligence,2012,28(1):51-105. [34]SUN R,LI Y J,CHEN C.Discussion on diversified insurancecontract dispute settlement mechanism.Insurance Studies,2010(12):108-114.(in Chinese) 孙蓉,李炎杰,陈辞.我国保险合同纠纷的多元化解决机制探析.保险研究,2010(12):108-114. [35]REN J M,ZHANG F.The construction of the multiple dispute resolution mechanism of the financial consumption——the research based on the perspective of online dispute resolution.West China Finance,2015(4):24-29.(in Chinese) 任建谋,张锋.金融消费多元纠纷解决机制构建--基于ODR视角的研究.西部金融,2015(4):24-29. [36]PRAKKEN H.On the problem of making autonomous vehicles conform to traffic law .Artificial Intelligence & Law,2017,25(3):341-363. [37]YANG M,JIANG Y,TIAN Y,et al.Impact of big data on china smart river basin[C]∥Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Intelligent Computation Technology and Automation.2014:304-307. [38]CAO Y,HE D K.Practical techniques for fast query over encrypted character data in database.Application Research of Computers,2009,26(2):736-738.(in Chinese) 曹杨,何大可.数据库加密字符串快速查询方法研究.计算机应用研究,2009,26(2):736-738. [39]OPIJNEN M V,SANTOS C.On the concept of relevance in legal information retrieval.Artificial Intelligence & Law,2017,25(1):65-87. [40]ZHANG Q,DU Y F,PENG L H.Application of intelligentagent technology in web information retrieving.Modern Electronics Technique,2006,16(16):75-77.(in Chinese) 张琼,杜友福,彭烈慧.智能agent技术在web信息检索中的应用.现代电子技术,2006,16(16):75-77. [41]DOSZKOCS T E.From research to application:The CITE na-tural language information retrieval system∥ACM Confe-rence on Research and Development in Information Retrieval.New York:Springer-Verlag,1982:251-262. [42]TANG Y L,LAI M S.Study of the application of ontology in natural language information retrieval.New Technology of Library & Information Service,2005(2):33-36.(in Chinese) 汤艳莉,赖茂生.ontology在自然语言检索中的应用研究.现代图书情报技术,2005(2):33-36. [43] GOLTZ N,MAYO M.Enhancing regulatory compliance byusing artificial intelligence text mining to identify penalty clauses in legislation∥Proceedings of Workshop on Mining and Reasoning with Legal texts.2017. [44]ZHONG Q T,FAN X Y,LUO X D,et al.An explainable multi-attribute decision model based on argumentation .Expert Systems with Applications,2019,117:42-61. [45]RUTKIN A.The judge is a robot.New Scientist,2014,222(2973):24-24. [46]KORB W,ENGEL D,BOESECKE R,et al.Development and first patient trial of a surgical robot for complex trajectory mil-ling.Computer Aided Surgery Official Journal of the International Society for Computer Aided Surgery,2003,8(5):247-248. [47]HE H B.On the abiding force of administrative action on civil adjudication.China Legal Science,2008(2):94-112.(in Chinese) 何海波.行政行为对民事审判的拘束力.中国法学,2008(2):94-112. [48]TAYLOR J B.The supreme court and political eras:A perspective on judicial power in a democratic polity.Review of Politics,1992,54(3):345-368. [49]SUSSKIND R E.Expert systems in law:A jurisprudential approach to artificial intelligence and legal reasoning .Modern Law Review,2011,49(2):168-194. [50]AIRES J P,PINHEIRO D,LIMA V S D,et al.Norm conflictidentification in contracts.Artificial Intelligence & Law,2017,25(4):1-32. [51]ADORMI G,ZOCK M.Trends in natural language generation:An artificial intelligence perspective.Berlin:Springer,1996:68-87. [52]MCFARLAND D A,LEWIS K,GOLDBERG A.Sociology inthe era of big data:The ascent of forensic social science.American Sociologist,2016,47(1):12-35. [53]KIRALY J,RIDGE P M,HOLVATH Z.Intelligent assistantfor use with a local computer and with the Internet:U.S.Patent No 6,088,731.2000. [54] GIBBON A.LawGeexAI versus lawyer NDA contract challenge sees technology win .https://www.socialmediaportal.com/News/2018/02/LawGeex-AI-versus-lawyer-NDA-con-tract-challenge-sees-technology-win.a-spx. [55] WEN X H.Morgan general AI assists counsel 360 thousandhours of manpower work to seconds .Big data Era,2017,2(2):74-74. [56]GERBER M S.Predicting crime using twitter and kernel density estimation.Decision Suport Systems,2014,61(1):115-125. [57]TABERNACKA M,WOLNY M.The position of an assistant in the prosecutor’s office——legal conditions and practice.Journal of Organic Chemistry,2013,71(19):7494-7495. [58]KENDRICK P,CRIADO N,HUSSAIN A,et al.A self-organi-sing multi-agent system for decentralised forensic investigations .Expert Systems with Applications,2018,102(102):12-26. [59]MA W J,LUO X D,LIU W R.An ambiguity aversion frame-work of security games under ambiguities[C]∥Proceedings of the 23rd International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence.AAAI Press,2013:271-278. [60]MA W J,LIU W R,MILLER P,et al.A game-theoreticapproach for threats detection and intervention in surveillance[C]∥Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Autonomous Agents and Multiagent Systems.2014:1565-1566. [61]ZHANG Y Z,LUO X D,MA W J.Security games with ambi-guous information about attacker types∥AI 2013:Advances in Artificial Intelligence.Springer International Publi-shing,2013:14-25. [62]ZHANG Y Z,LUO X D.Security games with partial surveil-lance[C]∥Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Autonomous Agents and Multiagent Systems.2014:1527-1528. [63]MA W J,MCAREAVEY K,LIU W R,et al.Acceptable costs of minimax regret equilibrium:a solution to security games with surveillance-driven probabilistic information.Expert Systems with Applications,2018,108:206-222. [64]WU J.Judgment reasoning-legal theory and system on the application of guiding cases.Hebei Law Science,2017,35(1):68-83.(in Chinese) 武静.裁判说理-适用指导性案例的理论与实践皈依.河北法学,2017,35(1):68-83. [65]AARNIO A.On legal reasoning.Annales UniversitatisTurkuensis,1977,144(2):18-20. [66]SUSSER D.Artificial intelligence and the body:Dreyfus,bickhard,and the future of AI ∥Philosophy and Theory of Artificial Intelligence.Berlin:Springer,2013:277-287. [67]VLEK C,PRAKKEN H,RENOOIJ S,et al.Modeling crime scenarios in a Bayesian network[C]∥Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Law.2013:150-159. [68]LODDER A R,OSAKMP A.Information technology & law-yers:Advanced technology in the legal domain,from challenges to daily routine.New York:Springer-Verlag,Inc.2006. [69]PRAKKEN H.Formal systems for persuasion dialogue .The Knowledge Engineering Review,2006,21(2):163-188. [70]PRAKKEN H.A formal model of adjudication dialogues .Artificial Intelligence & Law,2008,16(3):305-328. [71]LU E Q.Logical starting point of litigation mediation’s connection:preliminary argument on opinion-judging doctrine.Xiamen University Law Review,2013(2):175-194.(in Chinese) 陆而启.诉调对接的逻辑起点:意见裁判主义引论.厦门大学法律评论,2013(2):175-194. [72]ZHONG Q T,LUO X D,EEMEREN F H V,et al.The task model of court investigation in a multi-agent system of argumentation in court∥Logic,Rationality,and Interaction.Berlin:Springer,2013:296-310. [73]VERHEIJ B.To catch a thief with and without numbers:arguments,scenarios and probabilities in evidential reasoning.Law Probability & Risk,2014,13(4):307-325. [74]PEARL J.Probabilistic reasoning in intelligent systems:reaso-ning in intelligent systems .Morgan Kaufmann Publishers,1988:1022-1027. [75]BIEDERMANN A,TARONI F.Bayesian networks for evaluating forensic DNA profiling evidence:a review and guide to lite-rature.Forensic Science International Genetics,2012,6(2):147-157. [76]TIMMER S T,MEYER J C,PRAKKEN H,et al.A two-phase method for extracting explanatory arguments from Bayesian networks .International Journal of Approximate Reasoning,2017,80:475-494. [77] LUO X D,JENNINGS N R.A spectrum of compromise aggregation operators for multi-attribute decision making.Artificial Intelligence,2007,171(2-3):161-184. [78] LUO X D,ZHONG Q T,LEUNG H F.A spectrum of weighted compromise aggregation operators:A generalization of weighted uninorm operator.International Journal of Intelligent Systems,2015,30(12):1185-1226. [79]BEX F J,KOPPEN P J V,PRAKKEN H,et al.A hybrid formal theory of arguments,stories and criminal evidence.Artificial Intelligence & Law,2010,18(2):123-152. [80]VLEK C S,PRAKKEN H,RENOOIJ S,et al.A method for explaining Bayesian networks for legal evidence with scenarios .Artificial Intelligence & Law,2016,24(3):1-40. [81]CHUAH J.An analysis of the proposed EU legislation on supply chain security.Lloyds Maritime & Commercial Law Quarterly,2007(4):523-544. [82]LUITEN H.A legislative view on science and predictive models.Environmental Pollution,1999,100(3):5-11. [83]CHEN Y M.On the function of law undergraduate education in the training of foreign related legal professionals.Journal of Hebei Radio & TV University,2017,22(5):75-78.(in Chinese) 陈咏梅.论法学本科教育在涉外法治人才培养中的功能.河北广播电视大学学报,2017,22(5):75-78. [84]JIANG B X,ZHENG L H.Research on scientific legislation of the internet,big data and artificial intelligence.Law Science Magazine,2018,39(5):1-7.(in Chinese) 江必新,郑礼华.互联网、大数据、人工智能与科学立法.法学杂志,2018,39(5):1-7. [85] KERRIGAN C.Artificial intelligence and equity .Butter-worths Journal of International Banking and Financial Law,2017,32(7):430-433. [86]GEORGE B J.Extraterritorial application of penal legislation.Michigan Law Review,1966,64(4):609-638. [87]SCHNEIDER G,BALTZ K.The power of specialization:how interest groups influence EU legislation.Rivista di Politica Economica,2003,93(1):253-288. [88]ROHRER B.Accelerating progress in artificial general intelligence:choosing a benchmark for natural world interaction.Journal of Artificial General Intelligence,2010,2(1):1-28. [89]WANG F Y,WEI X D.Developing artificial wisdom to deal with the threat of artificial intelligence.Journal of Dialectics of Nature,2018,40(4):9-14.(in Chinese) 汪凤炎,魏新东.以人工智慧应对人工智能的威胁.自然辩证法通讯,2018,40(4):9-14. [90]ZHANG Y J.On the regulation of driverless cars by administrative law.Administrative Law Review,2018,1(1):68-77.(in Chinese) 张玉洁.论无人驾驶汽车的行政法规制.行政法学研究,2018,1(1):68-77. [91]SEHRAWAT V.Autonomous weapon system:Law of armed conflict (LOAC) and other legal challenges.Computer Law &Security,2017,33(1):38-56. [92]FALCINI F,LAMI G.Challenges incertification of autonomous driving systems[C]∥Proceedings of 2017 IEEE International Symposium on Software Reliability Engineering Workshops.2017:286-293. [93] LLIAIFAR A.Google adds Lexus RX450h to ongoing self-dri-ving car project .https://www.digitaltrends.com/cars/google-adds-lexus-rx450h-to-ongoing-self-driving-car-p-roject. [94] BEN S O.Should carmakers be liable when aself-driving car crashes .https://www.forbes.com/sites/omribenshahar/2016/09/22/should-carmakers-beliable-when-a-self-driving-car-crashes/#4ea00ff648fb. [95] SIDDIQUI F,LARIS M.Self-driving Uber vehicle strikes and kills pedestrian .https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/dr-gri-dlock/wp/2018/03/19/uber-halts-autonomous-vehicle-testing-after-a-pedestrian-is-struck/?ut-m_term=.a80bfbab6b0a. [96]TYLER D.Ford’s self-driving test car sever-elydamaged incrash .https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-01-12-/fords-self-driving-test-car-severely-damaged-crash. [97] LEE N.Uber’s transparency is key to making self-driving cars safer .https://www.engadget.com/2018/03/19/uber-transparency-self-driving-cars-safer/. [98]BANKS V A,PLANT K L,STANTON N A.Driver error ordesigner error:Using the perceptual cycle model to explore the circumstances surrounding the fatal tesla crash on 7th may 2016.Safety Science,2017,108:278-285. [99] RATTI C.The driverless city,safter streets .Neuroscience Journal,2014,84(3):52-55. [100] METZ R.Baiducould beat Google in self-driving cars with a totally Google move .https://www.technologyreview.com/s/609885/baidu-could-beat-google-in-self-driving-cars-with-a-totally-google-move/. [101] PRIGG M.Self-driving cars are five times more likely to have an accident,researchersreveal(but they say it’s human drivers who are at fault).https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3297415/Self-drivingcars-FIVE-TIMES-likely-accidentresearchers-reveal-says-human-drivers-fault.html. [102]PARK J,CHEN Z,KILIARIS L,et al.Intelligent vehicle power control based on prediction of road type and traffic congestions[C]∥Proceedings of IEEE-the 68th Vehicular Technology Conference.2008:1-5. [103]LUN Y.Status and trends of automatic driving industry.Telecommunications Network Technology,2017(6):33-36.(in Chinese) 伦一.自动驾驶产业发展现状及趋势.电信网技术,2017(6):33-36. [104] BROZEK B,JAKUBIEC M.On the legal responsibility of au-tonomous machines.Artificial Intelligence & Law,2017,25(3):293-304. [105]CONTISSA G,LAGIOIA F,SARTOR G.The ethical knob:ethi-cally-customisable automated vehicles and the law.Artificial Intelligence & Law,2017,25(3):365-378. [106]BENCH C T.Argument in artificial intelligence and law.Artificial Intelligence & Law,1997,5(4):249-261. |
[1] | 曹晓雯, 梁美玉, 鲁康康. 基于细粒度语义推理的跨媒体双路对抗哈希学习模型 Fine-grained Semantic Reasoning Based Cross-media Dual-way Adversarial Hashing Learning Model 计算机科学, 2022, 49(9): 123-131. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.220600011 |
[2] | 黎嵘繁, 钟婷, 吴劲, 周帆, 匡平. 基于时空注意力克里金的边坡形变数据插值方法 Spatio-Temporal Attention-based Kriging for Land Deformation Data Interpolation 计算机科学, 2022, 49(8): 33-39. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210600161 |
[3] | 闫佳丹, 贾彩燕. 基于双图神经网络信息融合的文本分类方法 Text Classification Method Based on Information Fusion of Dual-graph Neural Network 计算机科学, 2022, 49(8): 230-236. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210600042 |
[4] | 杨啸, 王翔坤, 胡浩, 朱敏. 面向设备状态监测的可视化技术综述 Survey on Visualization Technology for Equipment Condition Monitoring 计算机科学, 2022, 49(7): 89-99. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210900167 |
[5] | 侯钰涛, 阿布都克力木·阿布力孜, 哈里旦木·阿布都克里木. 中文预训练模型研究进展 Advances in Chinese Pre-training Models 计算机科学, 2022, 49(7): 148-163. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.211200018 |
[6] | 肖治鸿, 韩晔彤, 邹永攀. 基于多源数据和逻辑推理的行为识别技术研究 Study on Activity Recognition Based on Multi-source Data and Logical Reasoning 计算机科学, 2022, 49(6A): 397-406. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210300270 |
[7] | 李小伟, 舒辉, 光焱, 翟懿, 杨资集. 自然语言处理在简历分析中的应用研究综述 Survey of the Application of Natural Language Processing for Resume Analysis 计算机科学, 2022, 49(6A): 66-73. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210600134 |
[8] | 马瑞新, 李泽阳, 陈志奎, 赵亮. 知识图谱推理研究综述 Review of Reasoning on Knowledge Graph 计算机科学, 2022, 49(6A): 74-85. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210100122 |
[9] | 李野, 陈松灿. 基于物理信息的神经网络:最新进展与展望 Physics-informed Neural Networks:Recent Advances and Prospects 计算机科学, 2022, 49(4): 254-262. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210500158 |
[10] | 丛颖男, 王兆毓, 朱金清. 关于法律人工智能数据和算法问题的若干思考 Insights into Dataset and Algorithm Related Problems in Artificial Intelligence for Law 计算机科学, 2022, 49(4): 74-79. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210900191 |
[11] | 么晓明, 丁世昌, 赵涛, 黄宏, 罗家德, 傅晓明. 大数据驱动的社会经济地位分析研究综述 Big Data-driven Based Socioeconomic Status Analysis:A Survey 计算机科学, 2022, 49(4): 80-87. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.211100014 |
[12] | 孔钰婷, 谭富祥, 赵鑫, 张正航, 白璐, 钱育蓉. 基于差分隐私的K-means算法优化研究综述 Review of K-means Algorithm Optimization Based on Differential Privacy 计算机科学, 2022, 49(2): 162-173. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.201200008 |
[13] | 张虎, 柏萍. 融入句子中远距离词语依赖的图卷积短文本分类方法 Graph Convolutional Networks with Long-distance Words Dependency in Sentences for Short Text Classification 计算机科学, 2022, 49(2): 279-284. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.201200062 |
[14] | 陈志毅, 隋杰. 基于DeepFM和卷积神经网络的集成式多模态谣言检测方法 DeepFM and Convolutional Neural Networks Ensembles for Multimodal Rumor Detection 计算机科学, 2022, 49(1): 101-107. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.201200007 |
[15] | 张亚迪, 孙悦, 刘锋, 朱二周. 结合密度参数与中心替换的改进K-means算法及新聚类有效性指标研究 Study on Density Parameter and Center-Replacement Combined K-means and New Clustering Validity Index 计算机科学, 2022, 49(1): 121-132. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.201100148 |
|