面向家庭应用创新的Living Lab方法

doi:10.11896/j.issn.1002-137X.2017.02.006

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 互联网、普适计算和家庭机器人等计算机应用技术日益走进并深刻影响家庭生活。这些与家庭生活领域相适应的新技术的用户接受度、可用性及用户体验正成为越来越重要的问题。解决这些问题需要采用以用户为中心的研究、设计和创新方法。Living Lab用户协同创新方法具有用户主动参与、深入真实环境和纵向研究剖面等优点。介绍了把Living Lab方法用于家庭应用创新的研究与实践。首先介绍Living Lab的基本概念,然后重点介绍家庭应用设计开发中的Living Lab研究与实践案例,最后探讨其未来的发展方向和研究课题。

关键词: Living Lab,家庭,创新,以用户为中心设计

Abstract: Technologies,such as Internet of things,pervasive computing and home robots,are becoming ever more integral to our domestic lives.However,user acceptance,usability and user experience of these new technologies are beco-ming increasingly important issues,which need employing User-Centred-Design (UCD) methods and tools.Living Lab approach for studying technologies in domestic context has the advantages of involving user actively,going deep into user’s real-life environment and collecting data longitudinally.This paper first introduced the concept and the principles of Living Lab,then focused on the cases to adopt the Living Lab methods and tools in the home environments.At the end,the future research topics were explored.

Key words: Living Lab,Home,Innovation,User-centered design

卫伟杰,刘正捷. 面向家庭应用创新的Living Lab方法[J]. 计算机科学, 2017, 44(2): 56-64. https://doi.org/10.11896/j.issn.1002-137X.2017.02.006

WEI Wei-jie and LIU Zheng-jie. Living Lab Approach for Innovation in Domestic Applications[J]. Computer Science, 2017, 44(2): 56-64. https://doi.org/10.11896/j.issn.1002-137X.2017.02.006

参考文献

[1] NORMAN D A.The Design of Everyday Things[M].Dubleday,1990.
[2] COUGHLAN T,MACKLEY K L,BROWN M,et al.Current Issues and Future Directions in Methods for Studying Technology in the Home[J].Psychnology Journal,2013,11(2):159-184.
[3] POOLE E S,EDWARDS W K,JARVIS L.The Home Network as a Socio-Technical System:Understanding the Challenges of Remote Home Network Problem Diagnosis[J].Computer Supported Cooperative Work,2009,18(2/3):277-299.
[4] HAN L,LIU Z J,ZHANG J,et al.Remote User Experience Evaluation Review:Tools,Methods and Challenges [J].Computer Science,2014,1(10):196-203.(in Chinese) 韩立,刘正捷,张军,等.远程用户体验评估综述:工具、方法和挑战[J].计算机科学,2014,1(10):196-203.
[5] ERIKSSON M,KULKKI S.State-of-the-art in utilizing LivingLabs approach to user-centric ICT innovation-a European approach[J].Technology,2005,1(13):1-13.
[6] ERIKSSON M,NIITAMO V P,KULKKI S,et al.Living labs as a multi-contextual R&D methodology[C]∥ 2006 IEEE International Technology Management Conference.2006.
[7] FOSTAD A.Living labs for innovation and development of communication technology:a literature review[J].The Electronic Journal for Virtual Organisations and Networks,2008,10:99-131.
[8] ALMIRALL E,WAREHAM J.Innovation:a question of fit-the Living Labs approach[C]∥Symposium on Transversal Topics,Esade-HEC.Barcelona,Spain,2009.
[9] ELIZABETH B N.Sandersa,Stappers P J.Co-creation and the new landscapes of design[J].CoDesign,2008,4(1):5-18.
[10] PALLOT M.The Living Lab Approach:A User Centred Open Innovation Ecosystem.http://www.cwe-projects.eu/pub/bscw.cgi/715404.
[11] LI Q,LOU Q Y.Living Lab Literature review on foreign[J].Journal of Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications(Social Sciences Edition),2012,14(1):88-93.(in Chinese) 李青,娄秋艳.Living Lab国外研究概况综述[J].北京邮电大学学报(社会科学版),2012,14(1):88-93.
[12] WANG X Y,LOU Q Y,LU W K,et al.Practical education in Universities under the Living Lab innovation system[J].Journal of Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications(Social Sciences Edition),2013,1(1):104-110.(in Chinese) 王新宇,娄秋艳,卢文凯,等.Living Lab创新体系下的大学实践教育探索[J].北京邮电大学学报(社会科学版),2013,1(1):104-110.
[13] 纪阳.Living Lab创新体系概述[M].北京:人民邮电出版社,29-39.
[14] BERGVALL-KREBORN B,STST A.Living Lab:an open and citizen-centric approach for innovation[J].Int.J.Innovation and Regional Development,2009,1(4):356-370.
[15] BERGVALL-KREBORN B,et al.A Milieu for Innovation-Defining Living Labs[C]∥Proceedings of the 2nd ISPIM innovation symposium:Simulating recovery-the Role of innovation management.New York,USA,2009.
[16] CAO J,GOU X R.Exploration of campus innovation practice based on Lab Living model[J].Modern Educational Technology,2013,23(8):122-126.(in Chinese) 曹静,勾学荣.基于Living Lab模式的校园创新实践探索[J].现代教育技术,2013,23(8):122-126.
[17] BOYLE M,NEUSTAEDTER C,GREENBERG S.Privacy Factors in Video-Based Media Spaces[M]∥Media Space 20+Years of Mediated Life.2009:97-122.
[18] LEY B,OGONOWSKI C,MU M,et al.At Home with Users:A Comparative View of Living Labs[J].Interacting with Compu-ters,2015,27:21-35.
[19] FEURSTEIN K,HESMER A,HRIBERNIK K A,et al.Living Labs:A New Development Strategy[M]∥European Living Labs-A New Approach for Human Centric Regional Innovatio.2008:1-14.
[20] PALLOT M,TROUSSE B,SENACH B,et al.Living Lab Research Landscape:From User Centred Design and User Expe-rience towards User Cocreation[J].First European Summer School “Living Labs”,2010.
[21] BROWN M,COUGHLAN T,PLOETZ T,et al.Editorial:Methodsfor Studying Technology in the Home[J].Interacting with Computers,2015,27(1):1-2.
[22] PLTZ T,MOYNIHAN P,PHAN C,et al.Activity Recogni-tion And Healthier Food Preparation[J].Activity Recognition in Pervasive Intelligent Environment,2011,4:313-329.
[23] BROWN M,COUGHLAN T,BLUM J,et al.Tailored Scena-rios:A Low-Cost Online Method to Elicit Perceptions of Home Technologies Using Participant-Specific Contextual Information[J].Interacting with Computers,2014,27(1):60-71.
[24] COUGHLAN T,BROWN M,LAWSON G,et al.Tailored Scenarios:A Low-Cost Online Method to Elicit Perceptions on Designs using Real Relationships[C]∥Chi 13 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors in Computing Systems.2013:343-348.
[25] ODOM W,ZIMMERMAN J,DAVIDOFF S,et al.A fieldwork of the future with user enactments[C]∥Proceedings of the Designing Interactive Systems Conference.ACM,2012:338-347.
[26] MITCHELL V,MACKLEY K L,PINK S,et al.Situating Digi-tal Interventions:Mixed Methods for HCI Research in the Home[J].Interacting with Computers,2015,27:3-12.
[27] SUIJKERBUIJK S,BRANKAERT R,KORT Y A W D,et al.Seeing the First-Person Perspective in Dementia:A Qualitative Personal Evaluation Game to Evaluate Assistive Technology for People Affected by Dementia in the Home Context[J].Interacting with Computers,2015,27:47-59.
[28] KANIS M,ROBBEN S,HAGEN J,et al.Sensor Monitoring in the Home:Giving Voice to Elderly People[C]∥2013 7th International Conference on Pervasive Computing Technologies for Healthcare (PervasiveHealth).IEEE,2013:97-100.
[29] POOLE E S,COMBER R,HOONHOUT J.Disruption as a Research Method for Studying Technology Use in Homes[J].Interacting with Computers,2015,27(1):13-20.
[30] BROWN M,COUGHLAN T,LAWSON G,et al.Exploring Interpretations of Data from the Internet of Things in the Home[J].Interacting with Computers,2013,25(3):204-217.
[31] HESS J,LEY B,OGONOWSKI C,et al.New technology@home:impacts on usage behavior and social structures[C]∥Proceedings of the 10th European conference on Interactive tv and video.ACM,2012.
[32] BLOND S P L,HOLT A,WHITE P.3eHouses:A smart metering pilot in UK living labs[C]∥2012 3rd IEEE PES International Conference and Exhibition on Innovative Smart Grid Technologies (ISGT Europe).IEEE,2012:1-6.
[33] SCHWARTZ T,DENEF S,STEVENS G,et al.Cultivatingenergy literacy:results from a longitudinal living lab study of a home energy management system[C]∥Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems.ACM,2013:1193-1202.
[34] OBERZAUCHER J,WERNER K,MAIRBCK H P,et al.AVideophone Prototype System Evaluated by Elderly Users in the Living Lab Schwechat[M]∥HCI and Usability for e-Inclusion.Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2009:345-352.
[35] SCHUURMAN D,MOOR K D,MAREZ L D,et al.A Living Lab research approach for mobile TV[J].Telematics & Informatics,2011,28(4):271-282.
[36] OGONOWSKI C,LEY B,HESS J,et al.Designing for the Li-ving Room:Long-Term User Involvement in a Living Lab[C]∥Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems.ACM,2013.
[37] PANEK P,HLAUSCHEK W,SCHRENK M,et al.Experiences from User Centric Engineering of Ambient Assisted Living Technologies in the Living Lab Schwechat[C]∥International Conference on Concurrent Enterprising.2011:1-8.
[38] AGERSKOV M L,HOJ J C L.Lessons learned from the Danish EV living lab[C]∥Electric Vehicle Symposium and Exhibition (EVS27),2013 World.IEEE,2013:1-7.
[39] BENAVENT J,COLOBRANS J,MARI S,et al.Lessons learned from users:The development of the Living Lab 4 carers platform case[C]∥International Conference on Concurrent Enterprising.2011:1-8.
[40] BERGVALL-KREBORN B,HOWCROFT D,STHLBRST A,et al.Participation in Living Lab:Designing Systems with Users[J].Ifip Advances in Information & Communication Technology,2010,318:317-326.
[41] BOURGEOIS J,LINDEN J,PRICE B,et al.Technology Pro- bes:Experiences with Home Energy Feedback[J].Methods for Studying Technology in the Home,2013,7(7):58-62.
[42] JAKOBI T,STEVENS G.Always beta:cooperative design inthe smart home[C]∥ACM Conference on Pervasive and Ubi-quitous Computing Adjunct Publication.2013:837-844.
[43] LIEDTKE C,BAEDEKER C,HASSELKU M,et al.User-integrated innovation in Sustainable Living Labs:an experimental infrastructure for researching and developing sustainable product service systems[J].Journal of Cleaner Production,2015,97:106-116.
[44] BLASCOR,MARCO,CASAS R,et al.A smart kitchen forambient assisted living[J].Sensors,2014,14(1):1629-1653.
[45] PLOWMAN L.Researching Young Children’s Everyday Uses of Technology in the Family Home[J].Interacting with Compu-ters,2014,27(1):36-46.
[46] WINTHEREIK J C T,MALMBORG L,ANDERSEN T B.Li-ving Labs as a Methodological Approach to Universal Access in Senior Design[M]∥Universal Access in Human-Computer Interaction.Addressing Diversity.Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2009:174-183.
[47] KEYSON D V,MAHMUD A A,ROMERO N.Living Lab and Research on Sustainability:Practical Approaches on Sustainable Interaction Design[M]∥Ambient Intelligence.Springer International Publishing,2013:229-234.
[48] MALAVASI M,AGUSTO R,IOELE F M,et al.Living in the Living Lab! Adapting Two Model Domotic Apartments for Experimentation in Autonomous Living in a Context of Residential Use[M]∥Ambient Assisted Living.Springer International Publishing,2014:325-333.
[49] OLIVIER P,XU G,MONK A,et al.Ambient kitchen:designing situated services using a high fidelity prototyping environment[C]∥Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on PErvasive Technologies Related to Assistive Environments.ACM,2009.
[50] SHIPP V,COUGHLAN T,MARTINDALE S,et al.Wearables or infrastructure:contrasting approaches to collecting beha-vioural data in the home[C]∥Proceedings of the 2014 ACM International Joint Conference on Pervasive and Ubiquitous Computing:Adjunct Publication.ACM,2014:931-938.
[51] LIN C K E,WANG T H,YANG J F K.TOUCH Doctor－A Nu-trition Control Service System Developed under Living Lab Methodology[J].International Journal of Automation & Smart Technology,2012,2(3):253-263.
[52] ERICKSON T,PODLASECK M,SAHYU S,et al.The dubuquewater portal:evaluation of the uptake,use and impact of residential water consumption feedback[C]∥Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems.ACM,2012:675-684.
[53] BRUSH A J B,JUNG J,MAHAJAN R,et al.Digital neighborhood watch:investigating the sharing of camera data amongst neighbors[C]∥Proceedings of the 2013 Conference on ComputerSupported Cooperative Work.ACM,2013:693-700.
[54] YANG R,NEWMAN M W.Learning from a learning thermostat:lessons for intelligent systems for the home[C]∥Procee-dings of the 2013 ACM International Joint Conference on Pervasive and Ubiquitous Computing.ACM,2013:93-102.
[55] ANGROSINO M.Doing Ethnographic and Observational Re-search[M].SAGE Publications Ltd,2007.
[56] BLOMBERG J,BURRELL M.An ethnographic approach to design(2nd edition)[M]∥Sears A,Jacko J,eds.The Human-Computer Interaction Handbook.New York:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates,2007:965-988 .
[57] GOLD R.Roles in sociological field observations[J].SocialForces,1958,36(3):217-223.
[58] HUTCHNISON H,MACKAY W,WESTERLUND B,et al.Technology Probes:Inspiring Design for and with Families[C]∥Proc.of Chi’03.ACM,2003:17-24.
[59] GAVER W,DUNNE A.Projected Realities:Conceptual Design for Cultural Effect[C]∥Proc of the CHI 99 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems:the CHI is the limit.1999:600-607.
[60] GAVER W W,DUNNE A,PACENTI E.Cultural Probes[J].Interactions,1999,6(1):21-29.
[61] VISSER F S,STAPPERS P J.Contextmapping:experiencesfrom practice[J].Codesign,2005,1(2):119-149.
[62] VAN LEEUWEN J P,KARNIK M,KEANE K.DiscoveringMadeira:a case study of cultural probes[C]∥Procedings of the Second Conference on Creativity and Innovation in Design.ACM,2011:439-447.
[63] KOSKINEN I,KUUSELA K,BATTARBEE K,et al.Mor-phome:a constructive field study of proactive information technology in the home[C]∥Conference on Designing Interactive Systems.2006:179-188.
[64] SANDERS B N,STAPPERS P J.Probes,toolkits and proto-types:three approaches to making in codesigning[J].Codesign International Journal of Cocreation in Design & the Arts,2014,10(1):5-14.
[65] BROTMAN R,BURLESON W,FORLIZZI J,et al.BuildingChange:Constructive Design of Smart Domestic Environments for Goal Achievement[C]∥CHI.2015:3083-3092.
[66] SANDERS B N.Generative tools for co-designing[M].Springer London,2000.
[67] VISSER F S,VISSER V.Re-using users:co-create and co-eva-luate[J].Personal & Ubiquitous Computing,2006,10(2/3):148-152.
[68] SVENSSON J,ERIKSSON C I,EBBESSONE.User Contribution in Innovation Processes-Reflections from a Living Lab Perspective[C]∥46th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences.IEEE Computer Society,2010:1-10.

Metrics

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed