计算机科学 ›› 2026, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (6A): 251000061-9.doi: 10.11896/jsjkx.251000061
李晓1, 李欣怡2
LI Xiao1, LI Xinyi2
摘要: 人工智能技术凭借其自主性、不可解释性和系统性,正在催生新型犯罪形态,传统刑法罪名虽可通过扩张解释部分应对技术滥用型犯罪,但在保护客体特定性和行为要件局限性方面已显不足。当前人工智能犯罪规制存在新型犯罪行为立法缺失和滥用人工智能技术立法缺失双重困境。文中立足于数字文明转型背景下人工智能犯罪对传统刑法体系构成的结构性挑战,致力于构建一个集路径规制与体系构建于一体的一体化应对方案。在规制路径上,致力于从事前、事中与事后3个维度系统整合治理资源:通过技术性规制将法律义务嵌入代码架构,借助程序性创新破解司法证明中的算法黑箱,并构建基于控制力的协同治理体系以实现精准归责。在体系构建上,采取“解释论与立法论并重”的完善思路,对传统罪名进行有限度的扩张解释,以覆盖虚拟财产、系统受骗等新型行为样态;通过增设如非法利用算法操纵罪、深度伪造信息滥用罪等全新罪名,弥补由技术自主性引发的规范真空。构建人工智能技术事实的司法认定规范,以程序创新保障实体规则的落地。构建人工智能技术事实司法认定规范,将技术验证程序法定化,为前述路径与体系的司法落地提供程序保障,推动刑法从工业时代的惩戒法向数字时代的保障法转型,实现技术创新与刑事正义之间的动态平衡。
中图分类号:
| [1] BAI L T.The Identification Standard of “Misunderstanding” inthe Crime of Fraud [J].Chinese Journal of Law,2023(4):112-125. [2] LIU X Q.The Dilemma of Identifying Criminal Responsibility for Artificial Intelligence Crimes [J].China Legal Science,2022(5):89-103. [3] JI Y.No Need to Reconstruct the Criminal Responsibility System in the AI Era [J].Journal of Comparative Law,2019(4):123-137. [4] LIU X Q.On the Criminal Subject Status of Artificial Intelligence [J].Law Science Magazine,2020(3):45-58. [5] WANG S Z.The Interpretative Approach to Regulating Cybercrime [J].Modern Law Science,2021(2):78-92. [6] LIU X Q.The View of Criminal Law in the AI Era [M].Shanghai People's Publishing House,2019:156-160. [7] CHEN H B.Negation of AI's Criminal Subject Status and Its Practical Application [J].Social Science Journal,2021(6):92-98. [8] GOODFELLOW I,POUGET-ABADIE J,MIRZA M,et al.Generative adversarial nets [J].Communications of the ACM,2020,63(11):139-144. [9] Global Times.HK$200 Million AI Deepfake Fraud Case Oc-curred in Hong Kong [N].2024-03-15. [10] New Energy Vehicle News.Intelligent Driving Safety Incidents TriggerIndustry Reflection [N].2024-05-20. [11] IBM Security.X-Force Threat Intelligence Index 2024 [R].2024:15-18. [12] Group-IB.Hi-Tech Crime Trends 2023 [R].2023:27-30. [13] ZHANG Y Q,LI F F.Research on Safety Performance Evaluation of Autonomous Driving Systems [J].Acta Automatica Sinica,2023,49(5):1021-1035. [14] Zhejiang University AI Research Institute.AI Ethics and Regulation [M].Science Press,2023:156-160. [15] China Academy of Information and Communications Technology.AI Security White Paper(2023) [R].2023:45-48. [16] Peking University AI and Law Lab.Research on Legal Regulation of Algorithmic Discrimination [J].Peking University Law Journal,2024,36(1):89-105. [17] Supreme People's Court.Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Endangering Computer Information System Security [J].Gazette of the Supreme People's Court of the People's Republic of China,2019(5):12-15. [18] China Law Society Cyber and Information Law Research Society.2023 Annual Conference Proceedings [C]//Beijing:China Legal Publishing House,2023:123-126. [19] Beijing Haidian District People's Court. Civil Judgment:(2022) Jing 0108 Min Chu No.12345[M/CD].Beijing:Beijing Haidian District People's Court,2022. [20] Supreme People's Court Judicial Case Research Institute.Research Report on Judicial Application of AI 2023 [R].2023:34-37. [21] ZHANG M K.Criminal Law(6th Edition) [M].Law Press China,2023:45-48. [22] LIU X Q.The View of Criminal Law in the AI Era [M].Shanghai People's Publishing House,2019:45-48. [23] ZHANG M K.Criminal Law(6th Edition) [M].Law Press China,2023:156-160. [24] ZHANG B.Introduction to Explainable AI [M].Tsinghua University Press,2023:89-92. [25] WANG L M.Legal Transformation in the AI Era [J].China Legal Science,2023(4):56-68. [26] MA C S.Governance Innovation in the Smart Society [M].Law Press China,2023:134-137. [27] Supreme People's Court.Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Endangering Computer Information System Security [J].Gazette of theSupreme People's Court of the People's Republic of China,2019(5):12-15. [28] CHEN X L.Philosophy of Criminal Law [M].China RenminUniversity Press,2022:278-281. [29] ZHOU G Q.General Principlesof Criminal Law(4th Edition) [M].China Renmin University Press,2023:167-170. [30] LIANG G L.On the Rules of Criminal Law Interpretation and Application [J].Law Science,2023(3):78-91. [31] LI H.General Theory of Criminal Law(2nd Edition) [M].Law Press China,2023:203-206. [32] OUYANG B Q.The Path of Criminal Regulation of AI Crimes [J].Studies in Law and Business,2023(1):112-125. [33] JIANG T.Jurisprudential Proof of Criminal Regulation of AI[J].Peking University Law Journal,2023(4):89-102. [34] LAO D Y.AI and Criminal Regulation [J].ChineseJournal of Criminal Law,2023(2):56-69. [35] WANG Q.Research on Copyright Issues of AI-Generated Content [J].Law Science,2023(5):34-47. [36] BAI L T.Commentary onArticle 266(Fraud) of the Criminal Law [J].China Journal of Applied Jurisprudence,2025(2):182-197. [37] ZHANG J G.Criminal Risks in the Age of Artificial Intelli-gence:Focusing on Intelligent Robots [J].Journal of Chongqing University of Technology(Social Science),2019(8):87-94. [38] LI B Y,BAI Y,ZHAN X N,et al.Technical Characteristics and Evolution of AI-Generated Content(AIGC) [J].Library Information Knowledge,2023(1):66-74. [39] CHENG T.Risk Prevention and Criminal Regulation of Defective AI Products [J].China Price Supervision and Anti-Monopoly,2024(9):87-89. |
|
||