Computer Science ›› 2026, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (5): 1-12.doi: 10.11896/jsjkx.250600184

• Intelligent Education Technology • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Personalized Learning Resource Recommendation:Classifications,Algorithms,and Challenges

SUN Yifei, LI Yongan   

  1. School of Physics and Information Technology, Shaanxi Normal University, Xi’an 710119, China
  • Received:2025-06-26 Revised:2025-08-21 Online:2026-05-15 Published:2026-05-08
  • About author:SUN Yifei,born in 1983,Ph.D,associate professor,is a member of CCF(No.76686M).Her main research interests include smart education,intelligent optimization and scheduling,and data mining for complex systems.
  • Supported by:
    Shaanxi Province Education and Teaching Reform Research Project(23BY028),Key Teaching Reform Research Project of Shaanxi Normal University(22JG002),Shaanxi Province Natural Science Basic Research Program(2022JM-381,2017JQ6070),National Natural Science Foundation of China(61703256) and Central Universities Basic Scientific Research Business Fee Special Funds(GK202201014,GK202202003).

Abstract: Personalized learning resource recommendation represents an advanced form of deep integration between technology and education,which has received widespread attention from academia in recent years.Existing reviews have provided valuable discussions on basic theoretical frameworks,recommendation methods,and evaluation metrics.Building upon this foundation,the classification system and algorithmic analysis of personalized learning resource recommendations can be further enriched,especially through a comprehensive review of traditional recommendation methods and research on the application of emerging large language models in personalized learning recommendations.This review constructs a multi-dimensional classification framework,systematically categorizing personalized learning resource recommendations from three dimensions:application scenarios,algorithm categories,and learner characteristic modeling.It comprehensively explains the technical principles and latest developments of traditional recommendation algorithms,knowledge-based algorithms,machine learning algorithms,intelligent optimization algorithms,deep learning algorithms,and reinforcement learning algorithms.The review systematically analyzes the technical challenges facing personalized learning resource recommendations and the dilemmas from the learners’ perspective,and accordingly proposes future research directions such as integrating multiple recommendation methods,introducing educational theory guidance,and improving data quality.This review aims to provide educational technology researchers and practitioners with a systematic theoretical framework and technical roadmap to promote the continuous optimization and innovative development of personalized learning ecosystems.

Key words: Smart education, Personalized learning, Personalized resource recommendation, Recommendation algorithms, Machine learning, Intelligent optimization

CLC Number: 

  • TP391
[1]JIANG Q,ZHAO W,WANG P J,et al.Personalized Adaptive Online Learning Analysis Model and Implementation Based on Big Data[J].China Educational Technology,2015(1):85-92.
[2]MOU Z J.Rethinking and Resolving Personalized LearningTheory in the Era of “Artificial Intelligence+”[J].Journal of Distance Education,2017,35(3):22-30.
[3]LI G,JIANG Y J.Theoretical Construction and CharacteristicAnalysis of Personalized Learning[J].Journal of Northeast Normal University,2005(3):152-156.
[4]WANG J Y.Cultivating the Flower of Personalized Learningwith Artificial Intelligence as the Foundation[J].Shaanxi Education(Teaching Edition),2025(Z1):24-25.
[5]WANG X.Deep learning-based personalized learning recommendation system design for “T++” Guzheng Pedagogy[J].International Journal of Information Technology,2024,16(5):2775-2781.
[6]SONG P.Design and Application of Personalized Recommendation System for Online Learning Resources Based on Big Data[C]//2024 IEEE 3rd World Conference on Applied Intelligence and Computing(AIC).IEEE,2024:322-327.
[7]LI M,LI Z,HUANG C,et al.Edugraph:Learning path-based hypergraph neural networks for mooc course recommendation[J].IEEE Transactions on Big Data,2024(6):706-719.
[8]ARIF Y M,NURHAYATI H,KARAMI A F,et al.Game-Based Personalized Learning in the Metaverse Computer Virtual Laboratory:Improving User Experience with a Learning Material Recommender System[J].International Journal of Human-Computer Interaction,2025,41(19):12095-12112.
[9]MA F.Learning Behavior Analysis and Personalized Recommen-dation System of Online Education Platform Based on Machine Learning[J].Computers and Education:Artificial Intelligence,2025(8):100408.
[10]DONG F.Analysis of Personalized Recommendation System for Teaching Resources Based on Artificial Intelligence Assistance[J].Electronic Technology,2024,53(10):148-149.
[11]DONG M.Personalized Learning Path Recommendation Strategy Based on Subject Knowledge Graph[J].Modern Information Technology,2024,8(20):117-122.
[12]XIONG Y,REN C H,WU C,et al.Explainable Learning Path Recommendation Based on Knowledge Graph[J].Modern Educational Technology,2024,34(7):131-141.
[13]FAN Y X,DU J H,ZHANG J,et al.Adaptive Learning Path Recommendation Model for Dynamic Learning Environments[J].E-education Research,2024,45(6):89-96,105.
[14]LI J W,WU J H,JI Y L.Personalized Learning Path Recommendation for Adaptive Learning[J].Modern Educational Technology,2023,33(1):108-117.
[15]WANG J,LI Y Q,SHI Q.Personalized Learning Path Recommendation Integrating Multi-dimensional Preferences and Knowledge Tracing-Taking the “System Modeling” Course as an Example[J].Modern Educational Technology,2023,33(11):99-108.
[16]FENG S,ZHU Y,SONG M,et al.A Personalized Learning Path Recommendation and Verification Method Based on Similar Learner Determination[J].Computer Science,2023,50(S2):508-517.
[17]ZHENG Y,WANG D,XU Y,et al.A Multigranularity Learning Path Recommendation Framework Based on Knowledge Graph and Improved Ant Colony Optimization Algorithm for E-Lear-ning[J].IEEE Transactions on Computational Social Systems,2025,12(2):586-607.
[18]ZHOU Y T,CHU H,ZHU F F,et al.A Survey of Personalized Learning Resource Recommendation Based on Deep Learning[J].Computer Science,2024,51(10):17-32.
[19]HUANG M,CHEONG N,LIU J,et al.Literature Review ofPersonalizing Learning Recommendation Systems Using Machine Learning in Chinese Higher Education[C]//Proceedings of the 2024 7th International Conference on Educational Technology Management.2024:219-225.
[20]YUN Y,DAI H,ZHANG Y P,et al.A Survey of Personalized Learning Path Recommendation[J].Journal of Software,2022,33(12):4590-4615.
[21]CHEN S N,XU X H,YE Y,et al.Research on PersonalizedLearning Strategies Based on Learner Profiles[J].China Educational Technology & Equipment,2023(24):22-25.
[22]PENG W.Research on the Design of Personalized Learning System for Primary School Science Based on Knowledge Graph[D].Kunming:Yunnan Normal University,2024.
[23]ZENG H.Research on Personalized Course RecommendationAlgorithm Based on Learning Behavior Data[J].Information and Computer,2024,36(24):157-159.
[24]SONG Y Y,SONG Y.A Deep Learning-Based PersonalizedCourse Recommendation Model in Data-Driven Mode[J].Journal of Guiyang University(Natural Sciences Edition),2024,19(1):36-41.
[25]AMIN S,UDDIN M I,ALAROOD A A,et al.An adaptable and personalized framework for top-N course recommendations in online learning[J].Scientific Reports,2024,14(1):10382.
[26]ZHANG X X,TANG Y Q,ZHAO W,et al.Personalized Learning Resource Recommendation Based on Knowledge Graph and Graph Embedding[J].Computer Systems & Applications,2023,32(5):180-187.
[27]ZENG R K,LI Q Q,ZHOU W J,et al.Design and Implementation of Personalized Exercise Resource Recommendation System Based on Learner Profile[J].Enterprise Science and Technology & Development,2024(6):103-106.
[28]TANG Y.Research on Personalized Exercise RecommendationAlgorithm[J].Information Technology and Informatization,2023(2):100-103.
[29]SHARIF M S,TAMANG M T,MANI D,et al.Application of Clustering Algorithms to Enhance Personalized Learning Through Recommendation Model[C]//2024 International Conference on Innovation and Intelligence for Informatics,Computing,and Technologies(3ICT).IEEE,2024:547-552.
[30]CHU L X,TAO T,CHEN G L,et al.Knowledge Graph-Based Recommendation Model for Learning Resources in Shanghan Lun Curriculum[J].Modern Information Technology,2024,8(16):182-188.
[31]MA H,LI J Z,TANG W S,et al.Research Hotspots and Trends in Personalized Online Learning Resource Recommendation:A Visual Analysis Based on CNKI and WoS Literature(2011-2021)[J].Software Guide,2023,22(1):29-37.
[32]FENG Y J,SUN H J,YU D.Research on Personalized Resource Recommendation System Based on Learner Profile[J].Compu-ter Knowledge and Technology,2024,20(31):12-14.
[33]ALANWA-BELTRAN J.Personalized learning recommendation system in e-learning platforms using collaborative filtering and machine learning[C]//2024 International Conference on Advances in Computing,Communication and Applied Informatics(ACCAI).IEEE,2024:1-5.
[34]XI W.Research on E-learning interactive English vocabularyrecommendation education system based on naive Bayes algorithm[J].Entertainment Computing,2024,51:100732.
[35]LI S,LI D.Research on Personalized Learning Recommendation System based on Machine Learning Algorithm[J].Scalable Computing:Practice and Experience,2025,26(1):432-440.
[36]YANG Q,ZHANG J.Research on the Analysis of students’English Learning Behavior and Personalized Recommendation Algorithm based on Machine learning[J].Scalable Computing:Practice and Experience,2025,26(1):450-457.
[37]HE X,LIAO L,ZHANG H,et al.Neural collaborative filtering[C]//Proceedings of the 26th International Conference on World Wide Web.2017:173-182.
[38]GU A,DAO T.Mamba:Linear-time sequence modeling with selective state spaces[C]//First Conference on Language Modeling.2024.
[39]WEIKE L,YUANCAN Y,DAOKUAN W,et al.Research on intelligent recommendation system for personalized learning path based on computer deep learning[C]//2024 International Conference on Electronics and Devices,Computational Science(ICEDCS).IEEE,2024:752-759.
[40]YUN Y,DAI H,AN R,et al.Doubly constrained offline reinforcement learning for learning path recommendation[J].Knowledge-Based Systems,2024,284:111242.
[41]LI J,YU S,ZHANG T.Learning Path Recommendation Based on Reinforcement Learning[J].Engineering Letters,2024,32(9):1823-1832.
[42]CHEN Y D.Research on Personalized Learning Path Recom-mendation Algorithm Based on Reinforcement Learning[J].Technology Wind,2023(34):82-84.
[43]FENG Z,ZHANG J.Research on AI based Personalized Recommendation System for Foreign Language Learning using k-Nearest Neighbours[C]//2025 International Conference on Intelligent Systems and Computational Networks(ICISCN).IEEE,2025:1-7.
[44]LI C Y,WU Y Q,TANG Z K,et al.Personalized Learning Resource Recommendation Integrating Knowledge Graph[J].Mini-Micro Systems,2024,45(2):285-292.
[45]ZHAI X,WANG Y,LIANG L,et al.Personalized e-learning resource recommendation using multimodal-enhanced collaborative filtering[J].Knowledge-Based Systems,2025,319:113605.
[46]TRAN P D T,VU K B,DOAN M N,et al.Personalized learning paths recommendation system with collaborative filtering and content-based approaches[J].Science & Technology Development Journal:Economics-Law & Management,2024,8(2):5243-5253.
[47]CHENG Y.Research on Personalized Learning Recommendation Model Based on User Collaborative Filtering Algorithm[C]//2024 3rd International Conference on Robotics,Artificial Intelligence and Intelligent Control(RAIIC).IEEE,2024:389-392.
[48]XU Y H.Research on Personalized Recommendation Method ofAgricultural Platform Learning Resources Based on Collaborative Filtering[J].Science & Technology Information,2024,22(16):174-176.
[49]QI X,ZHAO J,HU G.Explore the personalized resource recommendation of educational learning platforms:Deep learning[J/OL]. https://www.informatica.si/index.php/informatica/article/view/5690.
[50]XU Y J,GUO A Y.Research on Personalized Learning Recommendation Algorithm Based on Deep Learning and PMF[J].Intelligent IoT Technologies,2024,56(1):37-40.
[51]LUO Q,LIU Z D.Research on Personalized Learning Resource Recommendation Algorithm Based on Semantic Web[J].Electronic Technology & Software Engineering,2023(6):189-192.
[52]HANG L.Design and Application of Personalized Learning Rec-ommendation System Based on Knowledge Graph[J].China Internet Week,2024(24):39-41.
[53]PENG F F,DAI X D,LUO L X.Knowledge Graph-Based Recommendation Algorithm for Digital Learning Resources in Computer Courses[J].Office Automation,2024,29(24):28-30.
[54]TZENG J W,HUANG N F,CHEN Y H,et al.Personal learning material recommendation system for MOOCs based on the LSTM neural network[J].Educational Technology & Society,2024,27(2):25-42.
[55]ZHOU X,LIU M,WU L.Research on Personalized LearningResource Recommendation Method for Students Supported by Artificial Intelligence[J].Journal of Combinatorial Mathematics and Combinatorial Computing,2025,127:1725-1736.
[56]WEN M.Research on Learning Path Recommendation Based on LSTM and Attention Mechanism Fusion[J].Computer Programming Skills & Maintenance,2024(12):38-41.
[57]DELIANIDI M,DIAMANTARAS K,MORAS I,et al.DK-PRACTICE:An Intelligent Educational Platform for Personalized Learning Content Recommendations Based on Students Knowledge State[J].arXiv:2501.10373,2024.
[58]ZHU M.Research on Personalized Resource RecommendationMethod Based on Large Language Model[J].Journal of Lanzhou University of Arts and Science(Natural Science Edition),2024,38(5):59-64.
[59]TANG X Y,LI B,ZHANG C J,et al.Learning Resource Recommendation Based on Semi-Autoencoder[J].Journal of Yangzhou University(Natural Science Edition),2023,26(1):74-78.
[60]WANG H,SUN D.Personalized Learning Resource Recommendation Algorithm Based on Improved Graph Neural Network and User Preference Clustering[J].Journal of Heilongjiang Institute of Technology,2022,36(6):30-34.
[61]MA B,KHAN M A Z,YANG T,et al.How Good Are Large Language Models for Course Recommendation inMOOCs?[J].arXiv:2504.08208,2025.
[62]DEHBOZORGI N,KUNUKU M T,POURIYEH S.Persona-lized Pedagogy Through a LLM-Based Recommender System[C]//International Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Education.Cham:Springer Nature Switzerland,2024:63-70.
[63]ZHANG X F,ZHANG L P,YAN S,et al.Personalized Learning Recommendation via Knowledge Graph and Large Language Model Collaboration[J].Journal of Computer Applications,2025,45(3):773-784.
[64]ZHAO C,YANG Y,YANG Y,et al.Personalized Learning Path Recommendation Driven by Multi-Modal Knowledge Graphs and Large Models Collaboration[C]//2024 International Conference on Information Technology,Comunication Ecosystem and Ma-nagement(ITCEM).IEEE,2024:227-232.
[65]LI H,GONG R,WANG C,et al.Research on Dynamic Learning Path Recommendation Based on Social Networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Consumer Electronics,2024,70(3):5903-5910.
[66]YANG S,WEI H,MA H,et al.Cognitive diagnosis-based personalized exercise group assembly via a multi-objective evolutionary algorithm[J].IEEE Transactions on Emerging Topics in Computational Intelligence,2023,7(3):829-844.
[67]SUN Y,CAO Y,WANG Z,et al.Personalized Exercise Group Assembly Using a Two Archive Evolutionary Algorithm[J].IEEE Transactions on Emerging Topics in Computational Intelligence,2025,9(3):2572-2583.
[68]WANG Z,SUN Y,CAO Y,et al.Adaptive Hierarchical Clustering Based Student Group Exercise Recommendation via Multi-objective Evolutionary Method[C]//International Conference on Neural Computing for Advanced Applications.Singapore:Springer Nature Singapore,2024:186-200.
[69]CAO Z.Research on Information Cocoon Effect in Online Lear-ning Resource Recommendation[J].Information Recording Materials,2025,26(2):45-47.
[70]GM D,GOUDAR R H,KULKURNI A A,et al.A digital recommendation system for personalized learning to enhance online education:A review[J].IEEE Access,2024,12:34019-34041.
[71]JING Y,JIA G.Application of Artificial Intelligence(AI) Technology in Intelligent Recommendation of English Personalized Learning System[C]//2024 3rd International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Autonomous Robot Systems(AIARS).IEEE,2024:455-460.
[72]WANG S.Multimodal Learning Data Intelligent PersonalizedLearning Resource Recommendation System for Web-Based Classrooms[C]//2024 6th International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Computer Applications(ICAICA).IEEE,2024:183-191.
[73]ZHANG F,FENG X,WANG Y.Personalized process-typelearning path recommendation based on process mining and deep knowledge tracing[J].Knowledge-Based Systems,2024,303:112431.
[74]YANG Z,ZHENG Y,YANG Y.Recommendations for Personalised Learning Paths[C]//2024 13th International Conference on Educational and Information Technology(ICEIT).IEEE,2024:36-40.
[75]LIANG K,YOU J.Research on personalized learning path recommendation model of artificial intelligence in new business[C]//2024 4th International Signal Processing,Communications and Engineering Management Conference(ISPCEM).IEEE,2024:801-806.
[76]SHI Y.A Classroom Personalized Learning Resource Recom-mendation Method[J].Information Technology,2023(11):158-161,167.
[1] DENG Xiaoheng, YU Zhan, XU Xuemei, LI Heng, ZHANG Hao, HU Chao. Building 3L-S3 Smart Ecosystem:Systemic Transformation of Graduate Education Models andOrganizational Forms in the Age of Artificial Intelligence [J]. Computer Science, 2026, 53(5): 50-58.
[2] LI Yili, YAO Jietong, LANG Jian, ZHU Guobin, CHEN Leiting, ZHOU Fan. Fake News Video Detection:Methods,Challenges,and Explainability Research [J]. Computer Science, 2026, 53(5): 174-192.
[3] CHEN Jun, TAO Wei, BAO Lei, TAO Qing. Momentum Method with Monotonical Coordinate-wise Step-sizes for Adversarial Attacks [J]. Computer Science, 2026, 53(5): 426-434.
[4] ZHENG Yi, JIA Xinghao, ZHANG Junwen, REN Shuang. Image Classification Based on Hybrid Quantum-Classical Long-Short Range Feature Extension Network [J]. Computer Science, 2026, 53(4): 277-283.
[5] JIANG Lei, WANG Zi, YANG Rong, HAN Wanglin. Human Motion Recognition Algorithm Based on Wearable Sensors [J]. Computer Science, 2026, 53(2): 342-348.
[6] WANG Yongquan, SU Mengqi, SHI Qinglei, MA Yining, SUN Yangfan, WANG Changmiao, WANG Guoyou, XI Xiaoming, YIN Yilong, WAN Xiang. Research Progress of Machine Learning in Diagnosis and Treatment of Esophageal Cancer [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(9): 4-15.
[7] LIU Leyuan, CHEN Gege, WU Wei, WANG Yong, ZHOU Fan. Survey of Data Classification and Grading Studies [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(9): 195-211.
[8] JIANG Rui, FAN Shuwen, WANG Xiaoming, XU Youyun. Clustering Algorithm Based on Improved SOM Model [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(8): 162-170.
[9] YANG Jixiang, JIANG Huiping, WANG Sen, MA Xuan. Research Progress and Challenges in Forest Fire Risk Prediction [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(6A): 240400177-8.
[10] WU Xingli, ZHANG Haoyue, LIAO Huchang. Review of Doctor Recommendation Methods and Applications for Consultation Platforms [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(5): 109-121.
[11] JIAO Jian, CHEN Ruixiang, HE Qiang, QU Kaiyang, ZHANG Ziyi. Study on Smart Contract Vulnerability Repair Based on T5 Model [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(4): 362-368.
[12] HAN Lin, WANG Yifan, LI Jianan, GAO Wei. Automatic Scheduling Search Optimization Method Based on TVM [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(3): 268-276.
[13] XIONG Qibing, MIAO Qiguang, YANG Tian, YUAN Benzheng, FEI Yangyang. Malicious Code Detection Method Based on Hybrid Quantum Convolutional Neural Network [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(3): 385-390.
[14] ZUO Xuhong, WANG Yongquan, QIU Geping. Study on Integrated Model of Securities Illegal Margin Trading Accounts Identification Based on Trading Behavior Characteristics [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(2): 125-133.
[15] SHANG Qiuyan, LI Yicong, WEN Ruilin, MA Yinping, OUYANG Rongbin, FAN Chun. Two-stage Multi-factor Algorithm for Job Runtime Prediction Based on Usage Characteristics [J]. Computer Science, 2025, 52(2): 261-267.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!