计算机科学 ›› 2022, Vol. 49 ›› Issue (4): 88-99.doi: 10.11896/jsjkx.210300219

所属专题: 大数据&数据科学 虚拟专题

• 数据库&大数据&数据科学 • 上一篇    下一篇

学术引用信息可视化方法综述

朱敏1, 梁朝晖1,2, 姚林1, 王翔坤1, 曹梦琦1   

  1. 1 四川大学计算机学院 成都 610065;
    2 四川大学吴玉章学院 成都 610207
  • 收稿日期:2021-03-22 修回日期:2021-08-06 发布日期:2022-04-01
  • 通讯作者: 梁朝晖(zhaohuileon@163.com)
  • 作者简介:(zhumin@scu.edu.cn)
  • 基金资助:
    四川省科技创新苗子工程(2019035)

Survey of Visualization Methods on Academic Citation Information

ZHU Min1, LIANG Zhao-hui1,2, YAO Lin1, WANG Xiang-kun1, CAO Meng-qi1   

  1. 1 College of Computer Science, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610065, China;
    2 Wu Yuzhang Honors College, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610207, China
  • Received:2021-03-22 Revised:2021-08-06 Published:2022-04-01
  • About author:ZHU Min,born in 1971,Ph.D,professor,Ph.D supervisor,is a senior member of China Computer Federation.Her main research interests include information visualization and visual analytics.LIANG Zhao-hui,born in 1999,is a member of China Computer Federation.His main research interests include information visualization and visual analytics.
  • Supported by:
    This work was supported by the Sichuan Science and Technology Innovation Seedling Project(2019035).

摘要: 学术文献中蕴含着丰富的引用信息,文献引用是科研评价和文献计量领域的主要分析对象和研究热点。相比基于数学和统计学的定量分析方法,利用可视化方法既可以实现引用信息时序、层次结构的直观呈现,也可以实现复杂引用网络的交互式挖掘,对科研评价改革和文献计量方法创新具有重要意义。文中首先介绍了近年来国内外学术引用信息分析的相关研究,总结了学术引用信息可视化的一般框架;然后根据实体评价和文献计量两类应用场景对可视化方法进行分类,详细阐述了可视化方法在两类应用场景中的研究现状和优缺点;最后指出了学术引用信息可视化面临的挑战和进一步探索的方向。

关键词: 科研评价, 可视化方法, 文献计量, 学术引用, 知识图谱

Abstract: Academic literature includes abundant citation information, which becomes the major analysis object and hot topic in both bibliometry and scientific research evaluation field.Compared with quantitative analysis methods based on mathematics and statistics, the use of visualization methods can realize the vivid presentation of citation information in time sequence and hierarchy, as well as the interactive mining of complex citation networks, which is of great significance to the reform of scientific research evaluation and the innovation of bibliometric methods.This paper introduces domestic and foreign relevant research on academic citation information analysis in recent years, summarizes the general framework of academic citation information visualization;classifies visualization methods according to two types of analysis tasks, entity evaluation and bibliometry, then elaborates the current research status, advantages and disadvantages of each type of methods, and finally points out the challenges and directions for further exploration of academic citation information visualization.

Key words: Academic citation, Bibiometry, Entity evaluation, Mapping of knowledge, Visualization method

中图分类号: 

  • TP391
[1] WU Z,WU J,KHABSA M,et al.Towards building a scholarly big dataplatform:Challenges,lessons and opportunities[C]//IEEE/ACM Joint Conference on Digital Libraries.IEEE,2014:117-126.
[2] ZHU M,WANG X K,YAO L,et al.A Survey of Visualization Methods for Urban Spatial Hot Spots Analysis[J].Journal of Computer-Aided Design & Computer Graphics,2020,32(4):551-567.
[3] JIANG L,ZHANG Q.Research on the Ranking Method of Academic Retrieval Results Based on Citation Sentiment Interaction[J].Information Studies:Theory & Application,2020,43(6):172-179.
[4] LIU X L.Global SCI Phenomenon and Impact Factor Cult[J].Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals,2012,23(2):185-190.
[5] LIU X L,DONG J J,ZHOU Z X,et al.A study on the relationship between publication cycle and impact factor of medical journals in China[J].Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals,2007,18(1):43-45.
[6] LIU X L,FANG H L,DING J,et al.Impact factors and 5-year impact factors of 1058 medical journals in the SCI database in relation to publication frequency[J].Chinese Journal of Scienti-fic and Technical Periodicals,2011,22(2):211-214.
[7] ZHANG L Z.Analysis of the role of impact factor in the evaluation of scientific and technical journals in China[J].Acta Editologica,2003,15(2):126-127.
[8] LIU J,TANG T,WANG W,et al.A survey of scholarly datavisualization[J].IEEE Access,2018,6:19205-19221.
[9] FEDERICO P,HEIMERL F,KOCH S,et al.A survey on visual approaches for analyzing scientific literature and patents[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2016,23(9):2179-2198.
[10] SNEIDERMANN B.The eyes have it:A task by data type taxo-nomy for information visualization[C]//Proceedings IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages.1996.
[11] COUNCILL I G,GILES C L,KAN M Y.ParsCit:an Open-source CRF Reference String Parsing Package[C]//LREC.2008:661-667.
[12] CORTEZ E,DA SILVA A S,GONCALVES M A,et al.FLUX-CIM:flexible unsupervised extraction of citation metadata[C]//Proceedings of the 7th ACM/IEEE-CS Joint Conference on Di-gital Libraries.2007:215-224.
[13] PENG F,MCCALLUM A.Information extraction from research papers using conditional random fields[J].Information Proces-sing & Management,2006,42(4):963-979.
[14] SHEN Q,WU T,YANG H,et al.Nameclarifier:A visual analytics system for author name disambiguation[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2016,23(1):141-150.
[15] BAI X,XIA F,LEE I,et al.Identifying anomalous citations for objective evaluation of scholarly article impact[J/OL].PloS one,2016,11(9).Https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0162364.
[16] GARFIELD E.Citation indexes for science[J].Science,1955,122(3159):108-111.
[17] HIRSCH J E.An index to quantify an individual’s scientific research output that takes into account the effect of multiple coauthorship[J].Scientometrics,2010,85(3):741-754.
[18] ZHOU Z,SHI C,HU M,et al.Visual ranking of academic in-fluence via paper citation[J].Journal of Visual Languages & Computing,2018,48:134-143.
[19] MAGUIRE E,MONTULL J M,LOUPPE G.Visualization ofpublication impact[J].arXiv:1605.06242,2016.
[20] YANG F,ZHOU J,WU J X.Research on text clustering me-thod based on information visualization technology[J].Journal of The China Society for Scientific and Technical Information,2005,24(6):679-683.
[21] BECK F,KOCH S,WEISKOPF D.Visual analysis and dissemination of scientific literature collections with SurVis[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2015,22(1):180-189.
[22] YOON T,HAN H,HA H,et al.A Conference Paper Exploring System Based on Citing Motivation and Topic[C]//2020 IEEE Pacific Visualization Symposium (PacificVis).IEEE,2020:231-235.
[23] CHOI G,LIM S,YOON T,et al.Citation network visualization of reference papers based on influence groups[C]//2018 IEEE 8th Symposium on Large Data Analysis and Visualization (LDAV).IEEE,2018:96-97.
[24] SHNEIDERMAN B.Tree visualization with tree-maps:2-dspace-filling approach[J].ACMTransactions on Graphics (TOG),1992,11(1):92-99.
[25] BERGSTROM P,ATKINSON D C.Augmenting the exploration of digital libraries with web-based visualizations[C]//2009 Fourth International Conference on Digital Information Management.IEEE,2009:1-7.
[26] ZHANG X,YUAN X R.Treemap Visualization[J].Journal ofComputer-Aided Design & Computer Graphics,2012,24(9):1113-1124.
[27] XIAO W D,SUN Y,ZHAO X,et al.Survey on the Research ofHierarchy Information Visualization[J].Journal of Chinese Computer Systems,2011,32(1):137-146.
[28] YANG Y B,LIU B,QI M Y.Review of information visualization[J].Journal of Hebei University of Science and Technology,2014,35(1):91-102.
[29] NEOL S,RAGHAVAN V,CHU C H H.Visualizing associationmining results through hierarchical clusters[C]//Proceedings 2001 IEEE International Conference on Data Mining.IEEE,2001:425-432.
[30] SHI L,SUN S,XUAN Y,et al.Topic:Toward perfect influence graph summarization[C]//2016 IEEE 32nd International Conference on Data Engineering (ICDE).IEEE,2016:1074-1085.
[31] HUANG Y,SHI L,SU Y,et al.Eiffel:Evolutionary flow map for influence graph visualization[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2019,26(10):2944-2960.
[32] FUNG T L,MA K L.Visual characterization of personal bibliographic data using a botanicaltree design[C]//Electronic Proceedings of IEEE VIS 2015 Workshop on Personal Visualization:Exploring Data in Everyday Life.2015.
[33] DÖRK M,RICHE N H,RAMOS G,et al.Pivotpaths:Strolling through faceted information spaces[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2012,18(12):2709-2718. [34] ZHANG J,CHEN C,LI J.Visualizing theintellectual structure with paper-reference matrices[J].IEEE Transactions on Visua-lization and Computer Graphics,2009,15(6):1153-1160.
[35] NOEL S,CHU C H H,RAGHAVAN V.Co-citation count vs correlation for influence network visualization[J].Information Visualization,2003,2(3):160-170.
[36] SHI L,TONG H,TANG J,et al.Vegas:Visual influence graph summarization on citation networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering,2015,27(12):3417-3431.
[37] WANG Y,SHI C,LI L,et al.Visualizing research impactthrough citation data[J].ACM Transactions on Interactive Intelligent Systems (TiiS),2018,8(1):1-24.
[38] PRICHARD A.Statistical bibliography or bibliometrics[J].Journal of Documentation,1969,25(4):348-349.
[39] CHEN Y,LIU Z.The rise of mapping knowledge domain[J].Studies in Science of Science,2005,23(2):149-154.
[40] MATEJKA J,GROSSMAN T,FITZMAURICE G.Citeology:visualizing paper genealogy[M]//CHI’12 Extended Abstracts on Human Factors Incomputing Systems.2012:181-190.
[41] HUANG T H,HUANG M L.Visualization of individual’sknowledge by analyzing the citation networks[C]//Computer Graphics,Imaging and Visualisation (CGIV 2007).IEEE,2007:465-470.
[42] PORTENOY J,WEST J D.Dynamicvisualization of citation networks showing the influence of scholarly fields over time[C]//International Workshop on Semantic,Analytics,Visualization.Cham:Springer,2016:147-151.
[43] ROSVALL M,BERGSTROM C T.Mapping change in largenetworks[J/OL].PloS one,2010,5(1).https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0008694.
[44] HEIMERL F,HAN Q,KOCH S,et al.CiteRivers:Visual analytics of citation patterns[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2015,22(1):190-199.
[45] MENG X F,CI X.Big Data Management:Concepts,Techniques and Challenges[J].Journal of Computer Research and Development,2013,50(1):146-169.
[46] DATTOLO A,CORBATTO M.VisualBib:A novel Web app forsupporting researchers in the creation,visualization and sharing of bibliographies[J/OL].Knowledge-Based Systems.https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0950705119303351.
[47] RUI J,YU S,YAN H,et al.Visualization and Forecast Analysis of Science and Technology Intelligence Based on Knowledge Graph[C]//2018 17th International Symposium on Distributed Computing and Applications for Business Engineering and Science (DCABES).IEEE,2018:44-47.
[48] SCHÄFER U,SPURK C.TAKE scientist’s workbench:semantic search and citation-based visual navigation in scholar papers[C]//2010 IEEE Fourth International Conference on Semantic Computing.IEEE,2010:317-324.
[49] SHIN M,SOEN A,READSHAW B T,et al.Influence flowers of academic entities[C]//2019 IEEE Conference on Visual Analytics Science and Technology (VAST).IEEE,2019:1-10.
[50] QIU J P,LI X T.Research on Knowledge Diffusion Based on Citation Web Mining and Timing Analysis[J].Information Stu-dies:Theory & Application,2014,37(7):5-10.
[51] CHEN C.The citespace manual[J].College of Computing and Informatics,2014,1:1-84.
[52] VAN ECK N J,WALTMAN L.Software survey:VOSviewer,a computer program for bibliometric mapping[J].Scientometrics,2010,84(2):523-538.
[53] YORK S N.Science of Science (Sci2) Tool[M].Springer,NewYork,2014.
[54] CHEN C.CiteSpace II:Detecting and visualizing emergingtrends and transient patterns in scientific literature[J].Journal of the American Society for information Science and Technology,2006,57(3):359-377.
[55] LIAO H,TANG M,LUO L,et al.A bibliometric analysis and visualization of medical big data research[J].Sustainability,2018,10(1):166.
[56] YANG J,CHENG C,SHEN S,et al.Comparison of complex network analysis software:Citespace,SCI 2 and Gephi[C]//2017 IEEE 2nd International Conference on Big Data Analysis (ICBDA).IEEE,2017:169-172.
[57] QIU X H,LI G J,XIAO M.Sci2-New Mapping KnowledgeAnalysis Software[J].Library Journal,2013,32(9):79-87.
[58] THIELE T,SOMMER T,STIEHM S,et al.Exploring research networks with data science:A data-driven microservice architecture for synergy detection[C]//2016 IEEE 4th International Conference on Future Internet of Things and Cloud Workshops (FiCloudW).IEEE,2016:246-251.
[59] BHARDWAJ A,MERCIER D,HASHMI H,et al.AcademicCommunity Explorer (ACE) for Syntactic,Semantic and Pragmatic Document Analysis[C]//2017 14th IAPR International Conference on Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR).IEEE,2017:262-267.
[60] ZIMMER B,SAHLGREN M,KERREN A.Visual analysis ofrelationships between heterogeneous networks and texts:An application on the IEEE VIS publication dataset[C]//Informa-tics.Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute.2017:11.
[61] HONG S H,HUANG W,MISUE K,et al.A framework for vi-sual analytics of massive complex networks[C]//2014 International Conference on Big Data and Smart Computing (BIGCOMP).IEEE,2014:22-28.
[62] ZIMMER B,JUSUFI I,KERREN A.Analyzing multiple network centralities with ViNCent[C]//Proceedings of SIGRAD 2012:Interactive Visual Analysis of Data.2012:87-90.
[63] HENRY N,FEKETE J D,MCGUFFIN M J.Nodetrix:a hybrid visualization of social networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Visua-lization and Computer Graphics,2007,13(6):1302-1309.
[64] KHALID A,AFZAL M T,QADIR M A.Citation network visua-lization of CiteSeer dataset[C]//2011 6th International Confe-rence on Computer Sciences and Convergence Information Technology (ICCIT).IEEE,2011:367-370.
[65] ALFRAIDI H,LEE W S,SANKOFF D.Literature visualization and similarity measurement based on citation relations[C]//2015 19th International Conference on Information Visualisation.IEEE,2015:217-222.
[66] YUAN S,TANG J,GU X T.A Survey on Scholar ProfilingTechniques in the Open Internet[J].Journal of Computer Research and Development,2018,55(9):1903-1919.
[67] LATIF S,BECK F.Vis author profiles:Interactive descriptions of publication records combining text and visualization[J].IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,2018,25(1):152-161.
[68] SALINAS M,GIORGI D,PONCHIO F,et al.ReviewerNet:Avisualization platform for the selection of academic reviewers[J].Computers & Graphics,2020,89:77-87.
[69] CORBATTO M,DATTOLO A.A web application for creating and sharing visual bibliographies[M]//Semantics,Analytics,Visualization.Cham:Springer,2017:78-94.
[70] SALINAS M,GIORGI D,PONCHIO F,et al.A Visualization Tool for Scholarly Data[C]//Smart Tools and Applications in Graphics(STAG 2019).2019:11-19.
[71] DENG D,WU Y,SHU X,et al.VisImages:A large-scale,high-quality image corpus in visualization publications[J].arXiv:2007.04584,2020.
[72] WANG Y,YU M C,SHAN G H,et al.Visual Analysis for Development Situation of Research Topics Based on Extended Bcp Index[J].Computer Systems & Applications,2020,29(7):56-69.
[73] ROSENTHAL P,MULLER N H,BOLTE F.Visual Analytics of Bibliographical Data for Strategic Decision Support of University Leaders:A Design Study[C]//Proceedings of the 14th International Joint Conference on Computer Vision,Imaging and Computer Graphics Theory and Applications (VISIGRAPP 2019).2019:297-305.
[74] SHI C,WANG H,CHEN B,et al.Visual Analysis of Citation Context-Based Article Influence Ranking[J].IEEE Access,2019,7:113853-113866.
[75] ZENG W,DONG A,CHEN X,et al.VIStory:interactive storyboard for exploring visual information in scientific publications[J].Journal of Visualization,2020,24(1):69-84.
[76] ZIMMER B.Guided Interaction and Collaborative Exploration in Heterogeneous Network Visualizations[D].Småland:Linnaeus University,2019.
[77] NAKAZAWA R,ITOH T,SAITO T.CoCoa:A Linked Net-work Visualization System of Co-citation and Co-author Relationships[C]//EuroVis (Short Papers).2019:109-113. [78] ZHAO Y,WEI H,WU S,et al.Topic-Aware Visual Citation Tracing via Enhanced Term Weighting for Efficient Literature Retrieval[C]//International Conference on Data Management Technologies and Applications.Cham:Springer,2016:79-101.
[79] TANG S Z,ZHANG Y F.DragDL:An Easy-to-Use Graphical DL Model Construction System[J].Computer Science,2021,48(8):220-225.
[80] CHAO L M,WANG R.Data Science Platform:Features,Techno-logies and Trends[J].Computer Science,2021,48(8):1-12.
[1] 徐涌鑫, 赵俊峰, 王亚沙, 谢冰, 杨恺.
时序知识图谱表示学习
Temporal Knowledge Graph Representation Learning
计算机科学, 2022, 49(9): 162-171. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.220500204
[2] 饶志双, 贾真, 张凡, 李天瑞.
基于Key-Value关联记忆网络的知识图谱问答方法
Key-Value Relational Memory Networks for Question Answering over Knowledge Graph
计算机科学, 2022, 49(9): 202-207. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.220300277
[3] 吴子仪, 李邵梅, 姜梦函, 张建朋.
基于自注意力模型的本体对齐方法
Ontology Alignment Method Based on Self-attention
计算机科学, 2022, 49(9): 215-220. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210700190
[4] 孔世明, 冯永, 张嘉云.
融合知识图谱的多层次传承影响力计算与泛化研究
Multi-level Inheritance Influence Calculation and Generalization Based on Knowledge Graph
计算机科学, 2022, 49(9): 221-227. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210700144
[5] 秦琪琦, 张月琴, 王润泽, 张泽华.
基于知识图谱的层次粒化推荐方法
Hierarchical Granulation Recommendation Method Based on Knowledge Graph
计算机科学, 2022, 49(8): 64-69. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210600111
[6] 王杰, 李晓楠, 李冠宇.
基于自适应注意力机制的知识图谱补全算法
Adaptive Attention-based Knowledge Graph Completion
计算机科学, 2022, 49(7): 204-211. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210400129
[7] 马瑞新, 李泽阳, 陈志奎, 赵亮.
知识图谱推理研究综述
Review of Reasoning on Knowledge Graph
计算机科学, 2022, 49(6A): 74-85. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210100122
[8] 邓凯, 杨频, 李益洲, 杨星, 曾凡瑞, 张振毓.
一种可快速迁移的领域知识图谱构建方法
Fast and Transmissible Domain Knowledge Graph Construction Method
计算机科学, 2022, 49(6A): 100-108. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210900018
[9] 杜晓明, 袁清波, 杨帆, 姚奕, 蒋祥.
军事指控保障领域命名实体识别语料库的构建
Construction of Named Entity Recognition Corpus in Field of Military Command and Control Support
计算机科学, 2022, 49(6A): 133-139. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210400132
[10] 熊中敏, 舒贵文, 郭怀宇.
融合用户偏好的图神经网络推荐模型
Graph Neural Network Recommendation Model Integrating User Preferences
计算机科学, 2022, 49(6): 165-171. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210400276
[11] 钟将, 尹红, 张剑.
基于学术知识图谱的辅助创新技术研究
Academic Knowledge Graph-based Research for Auxiliary Innovation Technology
计算机科学, 2022, 49(5): 194-199. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210400195
[12] 梁静茹, 鄂海红, 宋美娜.
基于属性图模型的领域知识图谱构建方法
Method of Domain Knowledge Graph Construction Based on Property Graph Model
计算机科学, 2022, 49(2): 174-181. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.210500076
[13] 徐进.
面向工业装配的知识图谱构建与应用研究
Construction and Application of Knowledge Graph for Industrial Assembly
计算机科学, 2021, 48(6A): 285-288. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.200600116
[14] 黄梅根, 刘川, 杜欢, 刘佳乐.
基于知识图谱的认知诊断模型及其在教辅中的应用研究
Research on Cognitive Diagnosis Model Based on Knowledge Graph and Its Application in Teaching Assistant
计算机科学, 2021, 48(6A): 644-648. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.200700163
[15] 李嘉明, 赵阔, 屈挺, 刘晓翔.
基于知识图谱的区块链物联网领域研究分析
Research and Analysis of Blockchain Internet of Things Based on Knowledge Graph
计算机科学, 2021, 48(6A): 563-567. https://doi.org/10.11896/jsjkx.200600071
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!